Blog
The Art of the Ask: How to Teach Fundraisers to Close More Donations
Because awkward doesn’t raise dollars—and confidence does.
Picture This:
You’re at a dinner party. You’ve just had the best dessert of your life. The host smiles and says, “So glad you liked it. Would you mind throwing $50 my way to help me bake more for the neighborhood?”
Cue the record scratch.
It’s not that you’re against cookies. It’s that… the ask came out of nowhere, with zero context and no clear purpose. And now you’re awkwardly looking for an exit—or at least another slice to justify the donation.
This is exactly what too many fundraisers do when they make “the ask.”
They’ve built relationships, hosted events, maybe even told a great story—but when it’s time to invite someone to give? They freeze. Or fumble. Or worse… never actually ask.
Let’s change that.
The Biggest Myth in Fundraising: “If They Want to Give, They Will”
Spoiler: They won’t.
Even your most loyal supporters need to be invited to act. Donors aren’t mind readers, and fundraising is not a game of subtle hints and hope. If your team isn’t asking clearly, confidently, and consistently, you’re leaving dollars (and impact!) on the table.
But here’s the good news: learning how to make the ask is a teachable skill. Like learning to ride a bike. Or parallel park without crying.
Why “The Ask” Feels So Hard (And Why It Doesn’t Have to Be)
Let’s call it what it is: asking for money feels vulnerable. Many fundraisers worry they’ll seem pushy, awkward, or too sales-y. But the truth? Asking is not selling—it’s inviting. It’s opening the door for someone to be part of something meaningful.
Think of it like this: you’re not asking them to give you money. You’re offering them a chance to create change, to be a hero in someone else’s story. You’re not saying, “Please give because we need it,” but “Here’s how you can make something amazing happen.”
How to Train Fundraisers to Actually Close More Donations
Alright, now that we’ve had our little mindset pep talk—let’s get practical. Teaching your fundraisers to confidently and consistently make the ask starts with structure, practice, and a little bit of reframing.
Here’s how to do it:
🧠 1. Shift the Mindset: From Money to Mission
Teach your team this one magic reframe:
“You’re not asking for money—you’re offering an opportunity to make an impact.”
This isn’t semantics. It’s a complete shift in energy. You’re not burdening the donor. You’re empowering them.
Training tip: Have fundraisers write 2–3 sentences that explain what a donor makes possible—not what your organization needs. Role-play saying it out loud until it feels natural.
📋 2. Use a Simple Ask Formula
Keep it straightforward. Here’s a proven 3-part structure that works for almost any conversation:
- Connect – Remind them why they care.
“You’ve always believed in creating safe spaces for youth.” - Share the Vision – Show what their gift could do.
“We’re launching a mentorship program that could double our reach next year.” - Make the Ask – Be specific and confident.
“Would you consider a gift of $250 to help us get started?”
Training tip: Have team members practice tailoring this structure to different giving levels—monthly donors, major donors, even corporate sponsors.
🔁 3. Practice Like It’s Game Day
You wouldn’t send your team into a big meeting without a run-through. Fundraisers should practice asks the same way athletes practice drills or actors rehearse lines.
Practice sessions should include:
- Role-playing with peers
- Practicing asks out loud (yes, it feels weird—do it anyway)
- Getting feedback in a safe, encouraging space
Bonus tip: Have your team practice in awkward scenarios too. (The donor is distracted. The answer is “not now.”) It builds resilience and helps them stay confident when the real-world conversations get wobbly.
📊 4. Set Clear Goals (and Celebrate the Small Wins)
Not every ask results in a donation—but every ask matters. Normalize tracking and celebrating:
- Number of asks made (not just gifts received)
- Number of follow-ups sent
- Number of positive donor conversations
Celebrate progress, not perfection. Recognition keeps your team motivated and helps create a culture where asking is the norm—not the exception.
💬 5. Equip Them with Language that Works
Too many fundraisers wing it. Give your team actual phrases, scripts, and templates they can customize and use.
Some handy lines to teach:
- “Would you be open to talking about how you can get involved this year?”
- “Can I share a specific opportunity that could really use your help?”
- “We’d love for you to be part of this—we’re inviting donors to give $X to help us [insert impact].”
Reminder: Specificity wins. “Support us” is vague. “Help 50 families access clean water this month” is powerful.
🤝 6. Normalize Rejection (It’s Not About You)
This might be the most important lesson of all. If your team’s afraid of “no,” they’ll hesitate to ask in the first place.
Reframe it like this:
- A “no” isn’t personal—it’s just information.
- Every “no” gets you closer to a “yes.”
- The donor is saying no to the timing or the offer, not to your mission.
Encourage fundraisers to reflect after each ask:
What went well? What would I do differently? What did I learn?
Fundraising Is a Conversation, Not a Transaction
When fundraisers learn to ask with clarity, confidence, and heart, magic happens. Donations increase. Donors feel more connected. Fundraisers actually enjoy their jobs more (wild, right?).
You don’t need a sales guru or a PhD in persuasion. You just need to help your team feel prepared, supported, and proud of what they’re inviting people into.
Let’s Make the Ask Together
Whether your team is brand new or seasoned-but-shy, they can learn the art of the ask—and love doing it. Training them to confidently invite donors into your mission is one of the best investments you can make.
Need help building those muscles? Want a team training, roleplay guide, or custom scripts?
👉 Let’s make this happen—contact us today, and let’s close more donations together.
Impact doesn’t happen by accident. But it does start with asking.