Blog
The Secret to Writing Fundraising Emails That Convert
Imagine this: you’re about to open your inbox, and there it is—an email with the subject line, “We Need Your Help!” You sigh, because so does everyone else, and your finger hovers over delete.
That’s the harsh reality: people don’t open (or act on) fundraising emails just because you send them. They open and act because the email connects. The secret isn’t a magic subject line generator or a hacky formula. The secret is treating your donors like people, not ATM machines with Wi-Fi.
So, let’s roll up our sleeves and talk about how to write fundraising emails that don’t just get opened—they actually inspire action.
Why Fundraising Emails Fail (And How to Avoid the Pitfalls)
Too many fundraising emails fall flat because they sound robotic, vague, or worse—desperate. Think of it like hosting a dinner party where you spend the whole time asking your guests to wash the dishes. Not exactly charming.
Here’s where most fundraising emails go wrong:
- The subject line is boring. “Monthly Newsletter” might as well say, “Ignore me.”
- They start with the organization instead of the donor. If your first line is “We at XYZ Nonprofit…,” you’ve already lost them.
- The ask is muddy. If readers have to scroll twice to figure out what you want them to do, they’ll close the tab.
The good news? Each of these is fixable.
Think of Emails as Conversations, Not Announcements
Fundraising emails work best when they feel like a personal note, not a press release. Pretend you’re writing to one person—a supporter you know and care about—not blasting a message to “everyone on the list.”
👉 Pro tip: Before you hit send, ask yourself, Would I actually read this if it landed in my inbox? If the answer is no, time to rework it.
Anatomy of a High-Converting Fundraising Email
Let’s break down the must-have ingredients.
1. A Subject Line That Earns the Click
Your subject line is your email’s front door. If it’s uninviting, no one comes in.
- Keep it short (under 50 characters).
- Create curiosity: “You made this possible…”
- Use urgency sparingly: “Deadline tonight: Double your gift.”
- Avoid shouting: Subject lines in ALL CAPS are the email equivalent of yelling in a library.
2. A Personal Opening
“Dear Friend” feels like junk mail. Instead, use their name if you can, or start with a hook:
- “I want to tell you about a little girl named Katelyn…”
- “You did something amazing last year…”
3. A Story That Shows, Not Tells
Humans connect with humans, not statistics. Numbers are powerful, but they work best when wrapped in a story. Instead of, “1 in 5 families struggle with food insecurity,” try:
“Last week, Sarah walked into our pantry holding her toddler’s hand. She didn’t know how she was going to feed her family that night. Because of you, she left with bags of groceries and hope.”
4. A Clear, Single Ask
Here’s where most emails get wobbly. Don’t ask donors to give and volunteer and sign up for your gala and share on Facebook. One email, one call-to-action. Period.
- Bad: “Donate, follow us, and buy tickets today!”
- Good: “Will you give $25 today to provide meals for a family in need?”
5. A Button That Pops
Links are fine, but buttons are better. Make it obvious where they should click. And don’t get cute with the button text—“Donate Now” or “Give $25 Today” works far better than “Be a Hero.”
6. A Warm, Human Close
End like a person, not an auto-bot. Sign off with your name, maybe even add a short P.S. (They’re one of the most read parts of any email.)
“With gratitude,
Emily, Development Director”
Rookie Mistakes to Ditch
Since we’re being real, here are a few habits to drop immediately:
- The wall of text. No one is reading a 1,000-word email on their phone. Break it up with short paragraphs, bold text, and bullet points.
- Overusing jargon. “Strategic initiative for capacity building” sounds impressive but means nothing to donors. Keep it plain.
- Forgetting mobile. More than half your readers are checking on their phone. If your email looks like a hot mess on mobile, you’ve already lost them.
- Only emailing when you need money. That’s like a friend who only calls when they’re moving. Stay in touch in between campaigns with updates, gratitude, and stories.
Best Practices That Actually Work
Here are some practical tips you can apply right away:
- Send from a person, not an organization. “Emily from Hope Center” gets more opens than “Hope Center Newsletter.”
- Use preview text wisely. Those little gray words under the subject line? Gold real estate. Tease the story or highlight the ask.
- Segment your list. A first-time donor shouldn’t get the same message as a 10-year supporter.
- Test and tweak. Try two subject lines. Track what works. Fundraising emails are part art, part science.
- Time it right. Tuesdays and Thursdays often get higher open rates, but the best timing depends on your audience.
Real-World Example
Let’s compare two approaches.
Version A:
Subject: We need your help
Dear Friend,
Our organization has been serving the community for 20 years. We rely on donors like you to continue our mission. Please make a gift today.
Version B:
Subject: You can feed a family tonight
Hi Sarah,
Last night, we helped a mom who wasn’t sure how she’d feed her kids. Your gift of $25 can provide dinner for another family just like hers. Will you give today?[Donate $25 Now]
Which one would you click? Exactly.
The Long Game: Relationships Over Transactions
Emails are just one piece of the puzzle. A donor who gives because of a great email needs follow-up: a thank-you, an update, maybe even a phone call. The email gets the door open, but the relationship is what keeps them giving.
Think of emails as first dates—you want them to say yes to dinner, but the real goal is building a long-term connection.
Final Takeaways
Here’s the quick cheat sheet for writing fundraising emails that convert:
- Subject line: short, curious, or urgent (but not spammy).
- Opening: personal, not generic.
- Story: lead with emotion, support with numbers.
- Ask: one email, one call-to-action.
- Design: mobile-friendly, easy to skim, with a clear button.
- Follow-up: thank them, update them, keep the relationship going.
Call-to-Action
You don’t need to be a copywriting genius to write emails that work—you just need to focus on people, not pitches. Start with one great story, make one clear ask, and keep it simple.
👉 Ready to take the stress out of donor communication? Karani helps you track donors, segment your lists, and keep your emails personal without the tech headaches. Book a demo today, and let’s make your next fundraising email the one that converts.